10 New Serious RPG Adventure Hooks (and 6 Funny Ones)

Versione in italiano qui.

Thirteen years ago, I searched online and compiled the list you'll find in this post (italian only).

I have a series of activities planned for the blog, and soon you'll find out how they tie into what I'm about to do.

In this 2025 version of the post, I’ll not only list the prompts, but have them face off (according to my taste) until I choose the one I like the most.

First, let’s list them. To make it an even number, I decided to offer 10 serious prompts and 6 funny ones.

10 Serious Adventure Hooks

  1. The Echo of the Past

    An ancient manuscript resurfaces, revealing that a legendary hero was in fact a bloodthirsty tyrant. His deeds, celebrated for centuries, hide a dark secret that threatens to rewrite history.
  2. The Silent Village
    The inhabitants of a village have vanished without a trace. The houses are intact, meals still warm. Only a whisper in the wind endlessly repeats a forgotten name.
  3. The Curse of the Stars
    Every night, a star falls from the sky, and with it, a new aberrant creature is born. Scholars fear the sky itself is dying, and with it, the entire world.
  4. The Broken Pact
    An ancient treaty between humans and forest creatures has been broken. Nature spirits awaken, bringing chaos and destruction, demanding justice for the offense.
  5. The Forbidden Legacy
    A young person discovers they are the last descendant of a banned bloodline of sorcerers. Their latent powers begin to manifest, attracting magical hunters and dark cults.
  6. The Sunken Temple
    During a drought, a lake’s waters recede, revealing a sunken temple. The inscriptions speak of a forgotten god and an imminent sacrifice.
  7. The King's Mask
    The king of a realm seems changed: colder, distant, inhuman. Rumors speak of a magical mask that has taken control of its wearer.
  8. The Sirens’ Song
    Sailors tell of an island that appears only during eclipses, inhabited by beings who sing irresistible melodies. Those who listen never return.
  9. The Infinite Library
    A dimensional portal leads to an endless library, where each book contains a person’s fate. But some volumes are beginning to rewrite themselves.
  10. The Eternal Judge
    A hooded figure appears in villages, judging the actions of the inhabitants and delivering immediate punishment. No one knows its origin or purpose.

6 Funny Adventure Hooks

  1. The Dragon Festival
    A small village holds an annual festival honoring an imaginary dragon. This year, a real dragon shows up, confused but curious to participate.
  2. The Shadow Thief
    The citizens of a town discover their shadows have vanished. An eccentric artist stole them to create his “ultimate masterpiece.”
  3. The Dancing Curse
    Anyone entering a certain tavern is forced to dance non-stop until dawn. The music seems to come from a magical jukebox with questionable taste.
  4. The Goblin Poet
    A goblin has decided to become a poet and challenges everyone to rhyme duels. His verses, however, have unpredictable magical effects.
  5. The Crafts Tournament
    A bored king organizes a tournament where participants must excel in common trades: cooking, sewing, gardening. The prize? A powerful magic item.
  6. The Flying Cow
    A cow has gained the ability to fly and is causing panic in the skies. The adventurers must discover the origin of the phenomenon and restore peace.

Now let’s set up the tournament board!

The Echo of the Past VS The Shadow Thief
The Broken Pact VS The King's Mask
The Eternal Judge VS The Crafts Tournament
The Dragon Festival VS The Flying Cow
The Dancing Curse VS The Sunken Temple
The Curse of the Stars VS The Infinite Library
The Goblin Poet VS The Forbidden Legacy
The Sirens’ Song VS The Silent Village

First Elimination Round

The Echo of the Past VS The Shadow Thief

The Echo of the Past appeals to me because, if built well, it can first cast doubt on the players’ actions, then place them in an awkward situation with the NPCs.
The Shadow Thief is interesting; magical painting used sparingly can really break the routine of a session.
However, my verdict gives the win to The Echo of the Past as it better supports a full-blown adventure (I can already picture it in three parts).

The Broken Pact VS The King's Mask

The Broken Pact is a classic and could even bring a social theme to the table for the right group.
The King's Mask feels a bit predictable, but with some tweaks it could be interesting (I’m thinking of a mask that actually made the king wise and whose loss now endangers the kingdom).
Neither excites me much, but thanks to the idea I had while reading, The King's Mask wins.

The Eternal Judge VS The Crafts Tournament

The Eternal Judge could be fun; the PCs might be hired by a wealthy but unpleasant man who fears being judged. The Judge might initially target the most hated villagers, then start eliminating everyone else. Lots of creative room here.
The Crafts Tournament is good for a break but wouldn’t sustain a full adventure.
The winner here is The Eternal Judge.

The Dragon Festival VS The Flying Cow

The Dragon Festival could work, but it feels like a side quest. In D&D, dragons are hard to manage at low levels, and the idea of a festival doesn’t fit well at high levels.
The Flying Cow is also a side quest, but with an advantage: a flying creature can challenge mid-level characters who are strong on the ground but don’t yet have flight abilities or items.
From that perspective, The Flying Cow wins.

The Dancing Curse VS The Sunken Temple

The Dancing Curse isn’t even a side quest — more of an encounter. Maybe the only item that can exhaust a powerful enemy, with a quest to lure them into the tavern.
The Sunken Temple leads directly to a dungeon, maybe with a time-based twist due to a curse or prophecy.
One-sided match: The Sunken Temple wins hands down.

The Curse of the Stars VS The Infinite Library

The Curse of the Stars could work for a whole campaign — either in an epic or a humorous tone (I’m thinking old-school mecha anime).
The Infinite Library has a great mood, but I think it would be hard to keep that atmosphere while the players are actively trying to resolve the mystery through quests.
So the winner here is The Curse of the Stars.

The Goblin Poet VS The Forbidden Legacy

The Goblin Poet is definitely fun, with just enough frustration for the players — especially if you're not good at freestyle rhyming.
The Forbidden Legacy suggests a classic escort quest. But if the cursed one is a player character, I can see a much more engaging story.
Despite my love for stories with redeemed goblins, The Forbidden Legacy wins.

The Sirens’ Song VS The Silent Village

A clash between sound and silence (you’ll soon find out why I’m surprised by this).
The Sirens’ Song lacks punch. In 100% of cases, if sailors tell players about a strange song leading people to a mysterious island, players think “sirens.” It needs a stronger hook.
The Silent Village reminds me of something I’m currently reading (a '90s work I'm progressing slowly through, but I’ll review it later). Interesting hook, but hard to find activities for the players.
Neither excites me much, but The Sirens’ Song wins.

Second Elimination Round

The Eternal Judge VS The Flying Cow: I choose The Eternal Judge because it has all the elements to support a full adventure.
The Echo of the Past VS The Sirens’ Song: Sirens barely scraped through earlier; The Echo of the Past wins this one easily.
The Curse of the Stars VS The Forbidden Legacy: Tough match. But personally, I prefer The Forbidden Legacy.
The King's Mask VS The Sunken Temple: Not a great matchup. I prefer the emotion of the mask, but The Sunken Temple wins for its adventure potential.

Semifinal

The Eternal Judge VS The Echo of the Past
The Forbidden Legacy VS The Sunken Temple
The Echo of the Past wins over The Eternal Judge by a small margin — this could've been a final.
The Forbidden Legacy wins over The Sunken Temple, especially in the version where the cursed character is a player.

Final

The Echo of the Past VS The Forbidden Legacy
Only in the version where the cursed one is the player, my winner is:
The Forbidden Legacy
 
Now it’s your turn! Let me know your favorite adventure hook by voting here.
The random pairings in this post were made using this tool.  

Commenti

Posta un commento

Post popolari in questo blog

10 spunti di avventura seri e 6 spunti divertenti

Sapete che non amo elencare spunti di avventura o cose del genere nel blog, se ne trovano mille in giro e di fatto, quando li ho dovuti usare per il blog (in all'opera tramite gli hook ) ho linkato un sito esterno. Quello che però mi succede spesso è che nelle liste che si trovano in giro ci siano pochi hook interessanti e molti hook banali. Con questo non voglio dire che i banali non servano, anzi sono ottimi per aggiungere sottotrame e cose del genere, ma potrebbe servire una lista di spunti più interessanti da usare per l'elaborazioni più importanti. Mi sono messo quindi a cercare online tra i tanti spunti quelli che ho considerato più interessanti e li ho rielaborati (e tradotti in italiano) per proporveli sul blog (va da se che sicuramente ce ne saranno altri mille altrettanto validi). Qui sotto la lista: Un cadavere morto in casa . Si può scegliere la sede dei PG o la casa di un membro e fargli trovare un cadavere morto all'interno. Il cadavere può avere su di s...
Continua a leggere

Recensione Monster of the week

Un amico mi ha contattato per qualche sessione di Monster of the week. Non conoscendo il gioco mi sono precipitato a vedere il sito ufficiale ( qui ) e costando solo 10$ il pdf originale ho pensato di acquistarlo e di iniziare a leggerlo. Al momento in cui scrivo non ho ancora giocato la prima sessione, però voglio darvi le mie impressioni tecniche sul manuale in se. Ah dimenticavo il costo per pagina del PDF è 10$ (al momento in cui scrivo quindi 8 euro) che divis su 201 pagine  fanno 0,04 centesimi a pagina, un record. Le premesse del gioco sono le seguenti: nel mondo ci sono i mostri nonostante la gente pensi che siano solo frutto dell'immaginazione di qualcuno. I testimoni oculari, normalmente capiscono che i mostri sono veri ma muoiono nel farlo. Alcuni individui però sono talmente folli o forti da sopravvivere e da mettersi a dargli la caccia. Questi individui sono i personaggi giocanti del gioco. Su questa base ci si può costruire molto, dall'emulare Buffy l'ammaz...
Continua a leggere

CR in D&D 3.5

La CR ( challenge rating ) o GS ( grado di sfida ) in italiano rappresenta in dungeons and dragons 3.5 il modo in cui il master tara gli incontri in base al gruppo dei personaggi. Chiunque continui ad osannare questo sistema (che fu un gran miglioramento rispetto alle precedenti edizioni ma che comunque presentava non pochi problemi) dovrebbe leggersi per bene il modo cervellotico in cui è stata gestita questa cosa! Oggi mi è arrivata una richiesta al riguardo e cercherò di spiegare al meglio la questione. Prima di tutto la richiesta: continua [...] ti scrivo, sperando che tu avessi più chiaro di noi (ho guardato forum, letto un sacco di articoli ma nessuno è stato chiaro) come funzionasse il concetto del grado di sfida...il nostro dubbio è: pagina 48 del manuale del master: il grado di sfida di un gruppo di 4 pg del 5°, è pari ad un mostro del 5°. Quindi 4 pg = 1 mostro... Questa equivalenza mi salta leggendo però pagina 37, dove dice che un PNG con livelli da stregone,...
Continua a leggere